Preview

Japanese Studies in Russia

Advanced search

The Korean issue at the Portsmouth Peace Conference

https://doi.org/10.24412/2500-2872-2021-4-113-133

Abstract

This study focuses on the efforts of the Russian delegation at the Portsmouth Peace Conference to include in the peace treaty a clause on Japan's recognition of the full independence of Korea and the early withdrawal of troops from its territory. The article was written on the basis of a wide range of sources, most of which are being introduced into scientific circulation for the first time.

The article provides a description of the international situation before the start of the peace negotiations. The attempts of the Japanese government to start peace negotiations with Russia in July 1904 are described, in particular, the detailed content of the proposal of the Japanese envoy to London T. Hayashi to the Russian Finance minister S.Yu. Witte about the meeting in Berlin to discuss the terms of peace is presented for the first time. Various opinions in the Japanese government about the supposed conditions of peace are considered, the change in the mood of the Russian government in favor of ending the war and the preparation of peace negotiations with Japan in March 1905 is shown, the meeting of the Minister of Foreign Affairs T. Delcasse with the Japanese envoy to France I . Motono on April 5 to clarify possible grounds for peace negotiations is described in detail.

The author considers the role of the US President T. Roosevelt in the preparation and conduct of the peace conference, as well as his attempts to ensure a leading role in the settlement of the Russo-Japanese conflict. In particular, this includes his proposal of “good offices” in March 1905 and the discussion of the issue of mediation at a meeting with аmbassador to Washington A.P. Cassini on March 30. His attempts to persuade the Japanese delegation to accept the terms are disclosed.

The article reproduces in detail the debates on the Korean question, the exposure of the aggressive nature of the Japanese demands by the Russian delegation at the conference, and advocacy for the preservation of Korean independence. It analyzes the arguments and demands of the Japanese delegates to the answers and proposals of the Russian representatives.

As a result of the research, the author came to the conclusion that the sovereignty of Korea was not shaken by the Portsmouth Peace Treaty. Although, under the treaty, Russia recognized Japan's predominant political, military and economic interests in Korea, the Russian government did not intend to violate the principle of Korean independence, which was the basis of Russia's policy in the Far East. At the same time, the recognition was stipulated by the obligation of Japan, fixed in the protocol of the conference, not to take measures affecting the sovereignty of Korea without the consent of the Korean government. This recognition became the only foreign policy obstacle to the complete destruction of the independence and territorial integrity of the Korean state by Japan for the whole five years after Portsmouth.

About the Author

B. B. Pak
Institute of Oriental Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation

Bella B. Pak - Doctor of Sciences (History), Head of the Cabinet (Laboratory) of History and Culture of Korea, Leading Researcher, Institute of Oriental Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences.

12, Rozhdestvenka Str., Moscow, 107031.



References

1. Gal'perin, A.L. (1951). Koreyskii vopros v mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniyakh nakanune anneksii Korei Yaponiei (1905-1910) [The Korean Question in International Relations on the Eve of the Annexation of Korea by Japan (1905-1910)]. Voprosy istorii, 2, 12-30. (In Russian).

2. Ignat'yev A.V. (1989). S.Yu. Vitte - diplomat [S.Yu. Witte as a Diplomat]. Moscow. (In Russian).

3. Iz arkhiva S.Yu. Vitte. Vospominaniya. Vol. 2. Rukopisnyye zametki [From the Archive of S.Yu. Witte. Memories. Vol.2. Handwritten Notes]. (2003). Saint-Petersburg. (In Russian).

4. Klyuchnikov, Yu.V. & Sabanin, A.V. (1925). Mezhdunarodnaya politika noveishego vremeni v dogovorakh, notakh i deklaratsiyakh. Ch. I [Modern international politics in treaties, notes, and declarations. Part I]. Moscow. (In Russian).

5. Korostovets, I.Ya. (1923). Stranitsa iz istorii russkoi diplomatii. Russko-yaponskie peregovory v Portsmute v 1905 g.: dnevnik I.YA. Korostovtsa, sekretarya grafa Vitte [A Page From the History of Russian Diplomacy. Russo-Japanese Negotiations in Portsmouth in 1905: Diary of I.Ya. Korostovets, Secretary of Count Witte]. Beijing. (In Russian).

6. Kutakov, L.N. (1961). Portsmutskii mirnyi dogovor (Iz istorii otnosheniy Yaponii s Rossiei i SSSR. 1905-1945 gg.) [Portsmouth Peace Treaty (From the History of Japan's Relations With Russia and the USSR. 1905-1945)]. Moscow. (In Russian).

7. Lukoyanov, I.V. (2010). Rossiya na Dal'nem Vostoke [Russia in the Far East]. Moscow: Rospen. (In Russian).

8. Ol'denburg, S.S. (2003). Tsarstvovanie imperatora Nikolaya II [Reign of Emperor Nicholas II]. Moscow: Eksmo. (In Russian).

9. Pak, B.D. (2004). Rossiya i Koreya [Russia and Korea]. Moscow: Institut vostokovedeniya RAN. (In Russian).

10. Park Jong-hyo. (1997). Russko-yaponskaya voyna 1904-1905 gg. i Koreya [Russo-Japanese War of 1904-1905 and Korea]. Moscow: Vostochnaya literatura. (In Russian).

11. Perepiska Vil'gel'ma II s Nikolayem II (1894-1914 gg) [Correspondence Between Wilhelm I and Nikolai II (1894-1914)]. (1923). Moscow, Petrograd. (In Russian).

12. Romanov, B.A. (1947). Ocherki diplomaticheskoi istorii russko-yaponskoi voiny 1895-1907. Izd.1-2 [Essays on the Diplomatic History of the Russo-Japanese War of 1895-1907. Edition 1-2]. Moscow, Leningrad. (In Russian).

13. Sbornik dogovorov Rossii s drugimi gosudarstvami (1856-1917) [Collection of Treaties Between Russia and Other States (1856-1917)]. (1952). Moscow. (In Russian).

14. Vitte, S.Yu. (1991). Izbrannye vospominaniya (1889-1904) [Selected Memoirs (1889-1904)]. Moscow. (In Russian).

15. Akagi, R.H. (1936). Japan's Foreign Relations. 1932-1936. A Short History. Tokyo.

16. British documents on the origins of the war. 1898-1914. (1926). Vol. IV. London: H. M. Stat. off.

17. Dennett, T. (1925). Roosevelt and the Russo-Japanese War. New York: Doubleday, Page & Company.


Review

For citations:


Pak B.B. The Korean issue at the Portsmouth Peace Conference. Japanese Studies in Russia. 2021;(4):113-133. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24412/2500-2872-2021-4-113-133

Views: 566


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2500-2872 (Online)