Ukrainian crisis in Japan’s domestic political discourse

The Ukrainian crisis, which came into its active phase in February 2022, led to the collapse of Russia’s relations with many countries, and Japan was no exception. The Japanese government expressed strong criticism of Russia’s actions and joined the anti-Russian sanctions with, probably, most vigor, compared to any other Asian nation. This makes the question about the reasons for such course pursued by Tokyo vis-à-vis Russia a particularly timely one. In Russia, there is a widespread opinion that such position held by Tokyo is caused mostly by pressure from the United States. Yet such view seems to be a gross simplification. This article attempts to analyze the positions of various participants of the Japanese foreign policy making process about the events unfolding in Ukraine. It shows that, even though all key parties, irrespective of their political orientation, take a critical stance towards the actions of the Russian Federation, their statements show some nuances reflecting their ideological priorities. For example, the ruling LDP emphasizes solidarity with the US; its junior coalition partner, Komeito, stresses humanitarian aspects and the role of the UN; the Japan Innovation Party criticizes the government for indecisiveness and calls for more active military policy, while the left-wing populist Reiwa Shinsengumi even refused to support the relevant Diet resolution to demonstrate its principled stance to the voters. There are indeed opinions which can arguably be called apologetic towards Russia. However, those holding such opinions are but a minority and are hardly able to alter the position of the government or the Japanese public as a whole. There is a virtual consensus about the issue, and nuances in the positions of major political forces are inconsequential. One would be justified to assume that, under any probable domestic political situation, Tokyo will not change its policy about the matter.

1. Arutyunyan, E. (2015). Politika Yaponii v regione Persidskogo zaliva v period irano-irakskoi voiny i irako-kuveitskogo konflikta [Japan's Policy in the Persian Gulf Region in the Period of the Iran-Iraq War and the Iraq-Kuwait Conflict]. Yearbook Japan, 44, 57–64. (In Russian).

2. Kazakov, O. (2019). Perekrestnyi god Rossii i Yaponii (2018-2019): dostizheniya i neudachi [Cross-Year of Russia and Japan (2018–2019): Achievements and Failures]. East Asia: Facts and Analytics, 2, 83–97. (In Russian).

3. Kazakov, O. (2021). O novykh tendentsiyakh v rossiisko-yaponskikh otnosheniyakh [On the New Trends in the Russian-Japanese Relations]. East Asia: Facts and Analytics, 3, 26–36. (In Russian).

4. Kistanov, V. (2017). Rossiya i Yaponiya: aktual'nye problemy otnoshenii [Russia and Japan: Current Problems of Relations]. Aktual'nye problemy sovremennoi Yaponii [Current Problems of Contemporary Japan], 31, 7–26. (In Russian).

5. Molodyakova, E. (ed.). (2008). Vneshnyaya politika Yaponii. Istoriya i sovremennost': Uchebnoe posobie [Foreign Policy of Japan. History and Contemporary Period: Teaching Material]. Moscow: Vostochnaya literatura. (In Russian).

6. Nelidov, V. (2019). Rossiisko-yaponskie dvustoronnie otnosheniya: predely sblizheniya [Russian-Japanese Bilateral Relations: Limits of Rapprochement]. East Asia: Facts and Analytics, 2, 65–82. (In Russian).

7. Nelidov, V. (2020). Novaya neopredelennost' v rossiisko-yaponskikh otnosheniyakh [New Uncertainty in Russo-Japanese Relations]. Japanese Studies in Russia, 4, 119–136. (In Russian).

8. Nelidov, V. (2022a). “Porochnyi krug” rossiisko-yaponskikh otnoshenii: sderzhivayushchie faktory i perspektivy uluchsheniya [“Vicious Circle” of Russian-Japanese Relations: Constraining Factors and Prospects for Improvement]. East Asia: Facts and Analytics, 1, 39–52. (In Russian).

9. Nelidov, V. (2022b). Vneshnepoliticheskii protsess v poslevoennoi Yaponii [Foreign Policy Process in Postwar Japan]. Moscow: Institute of Oriental Studies of RAS. (In Russian).

10. Panov, A. (1988). Yaponskaya diplomaticheskaya sluzhba [Japanese Diplomatic Service]. Moscow: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya. (In Russian).

11. Panov, A., Streltsov, D., Kireeva, A., Nelidov, V. (2019). Perspektivy razvitiya rossiisko-yaponskikh otnoshenii na novom etape [The Prospects of Development of Russian-Japanese Relations in the New Era]. Moscow: Russian International Affairs Council. (In Russian).

12. Streltsov, D. (2010). Vneshnepoliticheskii protsess v sovremennoi Yaponii [Foreign Policy Process in Contemporary Japan]. MGIMO Review of International Relations, 1 (10), 245–256. (In Russian).

13. Streltsov, D. (2021). Rossiiskoe napravlenie politiki Yaponii v Arktike [The Russian vector of Japan's policy in the Arctic]. Japanese Studies in Russia, 2, 110–126. (In Russian).

14. Streltsov, D. (2020). Rossiisko-yaponskie otnosheniya: dolgosrochnye faktory razvitiya [Russian-Japanese Relations: Long-Term Development Factors]. MGIMO Review of International Relations, 13 (3), 68–85. (In Russian).

15. Streltsov, D. (2022a)ю. Rossiisko-yaponskie otnosheniya posle Abe: novyi stress-test? [Russian-Japanese relations after Abe: A new stress test?]. Japanese Studies in Russia, 2, 120–133. (In Russian).

16. Streltsov, D. (ed). (2022b). Problemy istoricheskogo proshlogo v otnosheniyakh Yaponii so stranami-sosedyami [Problems of Historical Past in Japan’s Relations With Neighboring Countries]. Moscow: Aspekt Press. (In Russian).

17. Togo, K. (2005). Japan’s Foreign Policy, 1945-2003. The Quest for a Proactive Policy. 2nd edition. Leiden, Boston: Brill.

18. Hook, G. et al. (2012). Japan’s International Relations. 3rd edition. New York: Routledge.