Early history of Japanese Buddhism in Sanboe
https://doi.org/10.55105/2500-2872-2025-3-144-164
Abstract
The Three Jewels by Minamoto no Tamenori (Sanbôe, 984) shows, through a variety of didactic examples, how the Buddha, his teachings, and the monastic community are revered; the book was written by a layman and addressed to a laywoman preparing to take monastic vows. The narrator combines tales and quotations from books of the Buddhist canon with historical essays, mostly dealing with how Buddhist rites and customs appeared and took hold in Japan. The material is provided by earlier setsuwa tales, as well as kokushi state annals, kyaku court orders, engi temple legends, betsuden biographies of monks, along with the Chinese encyclopedic work on Buddhism Fayuan Zhulin (from which most of the quotations from the sûtras are taken), as well as the sûtras themselves (primarily the Lotus Sûtra) and some other Tripitaka texts. There is no consistent presentation of historical plots in Sanbôe; there are four stories about outstanding people of antiquity and a series of legends about the miracles of the sûtras, as well as an overview of the annual cycle of rituals, which includes biographies of the people who first performed these rituals in Japan. The beginning of the history of Japanese Buddhism here is attributed to Shôtoku-taishi at the turn of the 6 th — 7 th centuries, while earlier events are left aside. The activities of the 9 th century Tendai school teachers, Saichô and his closest disciples, are traced in particular detail. For some of the most important rites, historical excursuses are not given, probably because they had no founders; the Japanese community adopted them by itself, imitating the mainland community. For studying the history of Buddhism, Sanbôe is particularly interesting, as it reveals what information regarding the adoption of the Buddhist Dharma in Japan and the formation of the Sangha was selected for teaching a noble person and for entertaining reading. The article describes Tamenori’s approach to presenting the prehistory and history of rites, compares his interpretation of the initial stage of the Japanese Buddhist tradition with versions from other setsuwa collections, provides a translation of one of the stories about a rite (3—31), an analysis of its structure, and an overview of the historical episodes of Sanbôe.
About the Author
N. N. TrubnikovaRussian Federation
Trubnkova Nadezhda N., DSc in Philosophy, Leading Researcher
119571, Moscow, Vernadskogo Av., 82, Bldg. 1
References
1. Aleksandrova, N.V. (Trans. and comment.). (2012). Hsuanzang. Zapiski o Zapadnykh stranakh [epokhi] velikoi Tan (Da Tang Xiyu Ji) [Notes on the Western Countries [of the Era] of the Great Tang]. Moscow: Vostochnaya literatura. (In Russian).
2. Dulina, A.M. (2018). Metamorfozy Khatiman: groznyi bog voiny ili miloserdnyi bodkhisattva? Stanovlenie i evolyutsiya kul'ta bozhestva Khatiman v Yaponii v VIII—XIV vekakh [Metamorphoses of Hachiman: A Formidable God of War or a Merciful Bodhisattva? Formation and Evolution of the Cult of the Deity Hachiman in Japan in the 8 th — 14 th Centuries]. Moscow: Krug. (In Russian).
3. Fedyanina, V.A. (2025). Poklonenie Setoku-taisi v srednevekovoi Yaponii (v proizvedeniyakh Dziena) [Shôtoku Taishi Worship in Medieval Japan (in Jien’s Writings)]. Voprosy filosofii [Issues of Philosophy], 3, 175—185. (In Russian).
4. Ignatovich, A.N. (1998). Buddiiskaya filosofiya perioda Kheian [Buddhist Philosophy of the Heian Era]. In Buddiiskaya filosofiya v srednevekovoi Yaponii [Buddhist Philosophy in the Heian Era] (pp. 96—195). Moscow: Ladomir. (In Russian).
5. Kolyada, M.S. (2024). Demon ili budda: nastoyatel' Ryo:gen i ego obraz v pouchitel'nykh rasskazakh «Besed o delakh stariny» [Demon or Buddha: Ryôgen and His Image in The Setsuwa Tales of Kojidan]. Voprosy filosofii [Issues of Philosophy], 10, 154—167. (In Russian).
6. Meshcheryakov, A.N. (Trans. and comment.). (1984). Yaponskiye legendy o chudesakh (IX—XI vv.) [Japanese Legends of Miracles (9 th — 11 th Centuries)]. Moscow: Nauka, GRVL. (In Russian).
7. Meshcheryakov, A.N. (Trans. and comment.). (1995). Nihon ryoiki. Yaponskiye legendy o chudesakh [Nihon Ryoiki. Japanese Legends of Miracles]. Saint Petersburg: Giperion. (In Russian).
8. Meshcheryakov, A.N. (Trans. and comment.). (1997). Nihon shoki. Annaly Yaponii [Nihon Shoki. Annals of Japan]. Saint Petersburg: Giperion. (In Russian).
9. Meshcheryakov, A.N. (Trans. and comment.). (2018). Shoku Nihongi: prodolzhenie “Annalov Yaponii” [Shoku Nihongi: A Continuation of the “Annals of Japan”]. Moscow: Delo. (In Russian).
10. Os’kin, M.V. (2023). Kukai ob obryade podnosheniya svetil'nikov. Kukai. Blagopozhelaniye pri podnoshenii desyati tysyach svetil'nikov na gore Takano [Kûkai on the Light Pûjâ Ritual. Kûkai. Takano no yama mantôe no gammon]. Voprosy filosofii [Issues of Philosophy], 7, 159—165. (In Russian).
11. Rodin, S.A. (2014). Otnosheniya mezhdu lichnost'yu i gosudarstvom v Drevnei Yaponii (po materialam zhizneopisanii istoricheskoi khroniki «Shoku nihongi») [Relations between the individual and the state in Ancient Japan (based on the biographies of the historical chronicle “Shoku Nihongi”]. Voprosy filosofii [Issues of Philosophy], 2, 63—73. (In Russian).
12. Trubnikova, N.N., Bachurin, A.S. (2009). Istoriya religii Yaponii. IX—XII vv. [History of Religions in Japan. 9 th — 12 th Centuries]. Moscow: Natalis. (In Russian).
13. Trubnikova, N.N. (2012). Buddiiskaya obshchina v poru «Kontsa Zakona»: vzglyad iz Yaponii rubezha XII—XIII vv. [The Buddhist Community During the Mappô: A View From Japan at the Turn of the 12 th and 13 th Centuries]. Vostok-Oriens, 2, 125—140. (In Russian).
14. Trubnikova, N.N. (2025). Glavnyi smysl buddiiskogo ucheniya v «Sambo: ekotoba» [General Idea of Buddha’s Teaching in Sanbô ekotoba]. Voprosy filosofii [Issues of Philosophy], 4, 158—174. (In Russian).
15. Trubnikova N.N., Kolyada M.S. (2025). Rasskazy o monakhe Ku:ya i konfutsianskie korni amidaizma v Yaponii: opyt proverki odnoi gipotezy [Tales of the Monk Kûya and the Confucian Roots of Amidism in Japan: An Attempt to Test a Hypothesis]. Filosofiya religii: analiticheskiye issledovaniya [Philosophy of Religion: Analytical Studies], 2 (forthcoming). (In Russian).
16. Kamens, E. (1988). The Three Jewels. A Study and Translation of Minamoto Tamenori’s Sanbôe. Ann Arbor: Center for Japanese Studies, The University of Michigan.
17. Mabuchi, Kazuo, et al. (Eds.). (1997). Sanbô ekotoba. Chûkôsen [The Tree Jewels. A Selection of Favorite Tales]. Tokyo: Iwanami. (In Japanese).
18. Moerman, D. (1997). The Ideology of Landscape and the Theater of State: Insei Pilgrimage to Kumano (1090—1220). Japanese Journal of Religious Studies, 24 (3/4), 347—374.
19. Nakagawa, Satoshi. (Ed.). (2024-). Sanbô ekotoba [The Tree Jewels]. Retrieved from URL: https://yatanavi.org/text/sanboe/index.html (In Japanese).
20. Stone, J. (1985). Seeking Enlightenment in the Last Age: ‘Mappô’ Thought in Kamakura Buddhism: Part I. The Eastern Buddhist, 18 (1), 28—56.
21. Tanabe, W.J. (1984). The Lotus Lectures. Hokke Hakkô in the Heian Period. Monumenta Nipponica, 39 (4), 393—407.
Review
For citations:
Trubnikova N.N. Early history of Japanese Buddhism in Sanboe. Japanese Studies in Russia. 2025;(3):144-164. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.55105/2500-2872-2025-3-144-164